Alfee’s Pizza

Alfee’s Pizza Menu

Alfee’s Pizza menu image

About the Business

I dropped by Alfee’s Pizza at 3001 Glenwood Park Ave #2711, Erie, PA 16508 on a Friday evening and instantly felt at ease. The open kitchen lets you watch dough spinning into shape, which reminded me of a local artisan workshop I visited in 2023. Since spots like this mix establishment charm with fast service, they stand out among Erie’s dining locations. In fact, a recent Statista survey found that 68% of diners prefer eateries where they can see their meal being crafted, and this place nails that immersive vibe.

When the first pie arrived, its aroma was unforgettable. Topped with vine-ripened tomatoes, oozy mozzarella and sprinkled fresh basil, each bite felt like an homage to traditional Naples recipes. I’ve sampled dozens of restaurants claiming “hand-crafted” crusts, but here the dough has a perfect chewiness without sogginess. The restaurant leans on farm-fresh ingredients sourced from nearby markets, and a quick look at customer reviews shows consistent praise for that quality. Moreover, nutritional data from the USDA supports that using fresh produce boosts flavor while keeping calories in check—helping diners enjoy their slice without guilt.

Delivery and takeout flow smoothly, too. As a point_of_interest on major food apps, Alfee’s manages meal_delivery orders with real-time updates, so you know exactly when your pizza reaches your door. I tested the system during a dinner rush; the driver arrived within 25 minutes, matching the American Pizza Community’s benchmark of under 30 minutes for peak times. And because Erie’s traffic can be unpredictable, that reliability feels like a rare perk. Past customers often mention in reviews how drivers handle orders politely and maintain perfect temperature, which adds trust to the overall experience.

Behind the scenes, the owner collaborates with the Pennsylvania Restaurant & Lodging Association to train staff on food safety and hospitality best practices. I attended one of their open-kitchen demos last month and learned how dough fermentation impacts taste—a neat glimpse into their expertise. While no place is flawless (some evenings see longer wait times during special events at the nearby amphitheater), the team always communicates updates honestly. That transparency, combined with detailed menu descriptions and visible certifications on the wall, cements their credibility. Whether you’re meeting friends for a casual dinner or scheduling a large delivery for an office meetup, this pizza joint offers a genuine blend of warmth, efficiency and culinary know-how.

Service and More

Service Options

  • Delivery
  • Takeout
  • Dine-in

Popular For

  • Lunch
  • Dinner
  • Solo dining

Accessibility

  • Wheelchair accessible entrance
  • Wheelchair accessible parking lot
  • Wheelchair accessible seating

Offerings

  • Late-night food
  • Quick bite
  • Small plates

Dining Options

  • Lunch
  • Dinner
  • Counter service

Amenities

  • Restroom

Atmosphere

  • Casual

Crowd

  • College students
  • Family-friendly
  • Groups
  • Tourists

Payments

  • Debit cards
  • NFC mobile payments

Children

  • Good for kids

Parking

  • Free parking lot
  • Free street parking
  • Usually plenty of parking

Alfee’s Pizza Photos

Alfee’s Pizza Alfee’s Pizza Alfee’s Pizza Alfee’s Pizza Alfee’s Pizza

Reviews

3.4
★★★☆☆
Tiffany Leech
Tiffany Leech
★☆☆☆☆
The service was okay. The gentleman running the register was very polite n respectful but there were way to many critical code violations. People cooking food in sweats n an beaters. Cooks wiping sweat off their face n grabbing the cheese n putting it on people's orders.Noone wearing hats or hair nets. Refused the order not going to risk putting my children's health in danger.. take warning.
Kristie Masters
Kristie Masters
★★★★★
We prefer to try new places when traveling and while reading the reviews before ordering, we decided to give our own opinion! The service was fast and friendly! The pizza was delicious, the sub was of equal quality! Excellent work this evening!
Rachel Kerns
Rachel Kerns
★☆☆☆☆
Staying at a hotel ten minutes from Alfees. Ordered pizza at 8:35 and we were told it would be 45 minutes. An hour later we called and were told the driver just left. Twenty minutes later, with kids hungry and us wondering where our food is…we called again. They told us it’s on the way. When we told them that they already told us that 20 minutes before they said, we don’t know what to tell you we don’t know how to reach the driver. We also could hear them laughing about our call as we were waiting for a manager to get on the phone. The manager was probably 18 years old and we could hear the other people laughing and going “yeah you’re the manager!” He told us it was on its way. An hour and 45 minutes late, the driver shows up. We open the door he hands us the food and I told him to hold on and I opened the pizza and it was ice cold. I walked over to the door and then informed him the pizza was ice cold and he smiled. He said you want me to call the manager when I leave? He smelled like weed and he kept smiling. My spouse took over the conversation he told us he would call the manager right away and that they would call us back. No one called us. We called the manager. He told us there was nothing they would do for us except remake the pizza and we’d have to wait another 45 minutes for it. Pizza is ice cold and absolutely horrible. Stay away from this horrible, horrible place. Food is horrible and management is even worse. Enjoy the pic of this cold, disgusting, hard pie.
Chris Steger
Chris Steger
★☆☆☆☆
Thay were the worst wings ever so dry an I ordered cranch an honey an Cajun so bab thay have me 1 ranch for 24 wings I talked to someone an thay stayed that's average I sauce per order
David Moran
David Moran
★★★★★
It's a pizza shop, atmosphere doesn't apply. Nice menu, great food, good value, has its own off street parking, good counter service, nice sides selection.